For a second time, jury sides with family in Frankenmuth lawsuit - ABC 12 – WJRT – Flint, MI

For a second time, jury sides with family in Frankenmuth lawsuit

Posted: Updated:
FRANKENMUTH (WJRT) -

(03/27/2014) - For the second time, a family has won a legal battle against Frankenmuth over selling its land to Walmart.

Ronald Loesel and his family sued the city, after the city council passed a law restricting the size of stores.

The question now is, will Frankenmuth appeal the court's decision?
 
"It was hard keeping it together, its been a long, long haul," says Ron Loesel.

He describes the road traveled by himself, his wife Gayle, and other family members.  The Loesel's own about 38 acres on the north side of Frankenmuth.  About ten years ago Walmart offered the family four million dollars for the land. The company planned to build a store here.  The family and its attorneys claimed an zoning ordinance passed by the Frankenmuth City Council a short time later limiting building size on the property violated their 14th Amendment equal protection rights.

"It took awhile to figure out we were the only ones affected," he remembers.

A jury awarded the family $3.6 six million in 2010, but that verdict was overturned two years later.  A new trial began earlier this month, with the same result, but an even larger award for the family, $3.8 million.

"Its not the money as it is just the fact that someone agreed that what was done to us, wasn't right," Loesel says.

Walmart eventually gave up plans to build in Frankenmuth and the land is still being farmed by a Loesel family member. Further legal action is possible. The Loesel's attorney is Andrew Kochanowski.

"The city can appeal again, I feel very strongly and comfortable that they would lose that appeal outright and in very quick time,"says Kochanowski.

"Two independent juries, twelve people, found the same thing, hopefully that is the end of it," Loesel adds.

Frankenmuth City Manager Charles Graham says he is disappointed with the verdict, and the decision on whether or not to appeal will be made by the city's insurance liability provider.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Teen involved in shooting outside Bay County Juvenile Center had troubled past

    Teen involved in shooting outside Bay County Juvenile Center had troubled past

    Friday, August 29 2014 6:20 PM EDT2014-08-29 22:20:06 GMT
    We are learning new details about the teenager who was involved in Thursday's shooting outside a Bay County juvenile home.
    We are learning new details about the teenager who was involved in Thursday's shooting outside a Bay County juvenile home.
  • Mid-Michigan firefighters fill the boot for MDA

    Mid-Michigan firefighters fill the boot for MDA

    Sunday, August 31 2014 11:56 PM EDT2014-09-01 03:56:23 GMT
    (08/31/14) - Mid-Michigan firefighters were doing their part to help kids in need Labor Day weekend. The Saginaw Township Fire Department was one of many who took time out of their holiday weekend - to raise money for MDA."It means a lot to the guys, our department has a long history of doing this, i think this is our 35th to 40th year that we've been supporting muscular dystrophy, so it's a tradition. We give up a little bit of our holiday time to help out local families in need, it's defini...
    (08/31/14) - Mid-Michigan firefighters were doing their part to help kids in need Labor Day weekend. The Saginaw Township Fire Department was one of many who took time out of their holiday weekend - to raise money for MDA."It means a lot to the guys, our department has a long history of doing this, i think this is our 35th to 40th year that we've been supporting muscular dystrophy, so it's a tradition. We give up a little bit of our holiday time to help out local families in need, it's defini...
  • Man shot and killed, woman stabbed in Birch Run Township incident

    Man shot and killed, woman stabbed in Birch Run Township incident

    Sunday, August 31 2014 11:49 PM EDT2014-09-01 03:49:34 GMT
    (08/31/14) - A 57-year-old man was killed during a domestic dispute.The Michigan State Police say troopers and other emergency responders were called to a home in the 1300 block of Willard Road in Birch Run Township.The call came in around 11:55 p.m. for a domestic violence and felonious assault that was happening.When troopers arrived they found a 63-year-old woman with stab wounds, and the 57-year-old man dead.The woman was taken to Hurley Medical Center for for treatment.An autopsy is sche...
    (08/31/14) - A 57-year-old man was killed during a domestic dispute.The Michigan State Police say troopers and other emergency responders were called to a home in the 1300 block of Willard Road in Birch Run Township.The call came in around 11:55 p.m. for a domestic violence and felonious assault that was happening.When troopers arrived they found a 63-year-old woman with stab wounds, and the 57-year-old man dead.The woman was taken to Hurley Medical Center for for treatment.An autopsy is sche...
Powered by WorldNow

abc12.com

ABC12 Main Station
810-233-3130

Mailing Address:
2302 Lapeer Road
Flint, Michigan 48503

Powered by 

WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WJRT. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.